Alan Steel
01506 842365
MENU
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Close
    • About Us
    • What We Do
      • Close
      • What We Do
      • Our Services
      • Our Philosophy
      • Our Awards
      • Our Reputation
    • Who We Are
      • Close
      • Who We Are
      • Meet the team
    • Our Approach
    • Financial Planning
  • Testimonials
  • Investments
    • Close
    • Investments
    • Investment Advice
    • Portfolio Building
  • Pensions
    • Close
    • Pensions
    • Retirement Planning
    • Early Retirement
    • Pensions as simple as...
  • Tax
    • Close
    • Tax
    • Tax Advice
    • Tax Planning
    • When I'm Dead and Gone
    • Inheritance Tax
    • HMRC Digital Accounts
  • Insights & Media
    • Close
    • Insights & Media
    • Letters from Linlithgow
    • Informing You
    • Letter from America
    • See us in the Press
    • Master Investor
    • Points of Few
  • Contact Us
Independent financial advisers founded in 1975
Over £1.4 billion client funds under management
17 industry awards for advice since 1989

By Steve Forbes, ASAM Managing Director

Alan Steel Asset Management Ltd is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. The Financial Conduct Authority does not regulate tax advice.

This letter is the personal view of Steve Forbes. Please check the appropriateness to your individual position with your adviser before taking or refraining from any action.

Informing You

With a little bit of luck...

By Steve Forbes | Wednesday, 30 September, 2015

Imagine the scenario.  There are two fund managers, both of whom have demonstrated their expertise by producing well above average returns for their clients over the years.  In the late summer after much deliberation they both decide that Volkswagen shares would be an ideal addition to their respective funds.  They have made this decision having analysed the accounts, financial statements, projections and no doubt having meetings with senior management at the company.

Manager A makes their purchase at the beginning of September, but manager B decides to wait until they get back from holiday later in the month before going ahead.  You will be all aware of what happened next - out of the blue (exhaust smoke) 40% is wiped off the share price and while manager A is drowning their sorrows in a City hostelry, manager B is toasting their lucky stars by having another Pina Colada whilst swinging in a hammock!

Now, I do not intend to go into the morality of a company that deliberately installs a piece of software to cheat the system in millions of vehicles, but instead focus on the effect luck has on investment returns.

In this scenario manager A has used all of their experience before making this decision but an event that they would have no way of anticipating occurs and before you know it their performance relative to manager B is adversely effected.  However, does this make them a worse manager?  Of course not, but I bet a number of investors will be keener to invest with manager B in the future given they will have performed better this year.

There is no doubt that in the short term luck can have a far greater impact on returns than skill and experience.  In 2006 an American stock trading company asked ten Playboy playmates to each choose five different stocks to see how they performed over the next twelve months.  At the end of the experiment, five of the girls had beaten the index (and 90% of fund managers) with the top performer, Miss March 1998, achieving a return of 43% compared to the 13% increase in the S&P500.

Now, much as it might please some of our consultants to start holding meetings with playmates instead of fund managers, the returns these ladies achieved is purely down to luck and would be no different, although probably aesthetically more pleasing, than having Phil Taylor throw darts at a copy of the Financial Times and buying the shares in the companies where they landed.

So what can you do to try and remove the impact of luck and ensure that expertise has a greater impact on returns achieved?

Well focusing on long-term performance in measuring a manager’s ability is a good start.  The examples I have given show luck has a far greater impact on short-term returns yet 1 and 3 year performance league tables are still focused on, even though we would never suggest that anyone invest over so short a term.  In fact one company makes a great ballyhoo of publishing a list of “dog” funds that in the main is based on three year performance.

Ensuring that you have a spread of different managers with differing styles is another key factor in trying to get the odds in your favour as is investing globally as opposed to focusing solely on the UK.

However, undoubtedly the most important factor in trying to keep luck out of the equation is to keep your emotions in check and let your investments “run.”  Trying to guess markets is a quick way to the poorhouse as is constantly chasing performance, which as I have shown, in the short term, may well have been down to luck rather than good judgement.

As for Volkswagen, well their luck seems to have been exhausted!

©2023 Alan Steel Asset Management Limited is authorised & regulated by The Financial Conduct Authority. Please note that the Financial Conduct Authority does not regulate some forms of tax advice. Company Registration: SC58014

You should remember that the value of an investment and the income from it could go down as well as up. The return at the end of the investment period is not guaranteed and you may get back less than you originally invested.

The investment services and/or investments referred to in this website may not be suitable for you. If you are unsure we suggest you contact us to discuss matters further. If we believe our services are not right for you we will tell you.

When investing money, whether for income or growth, you are placing your capital at risk as the value of investments may vary, so you could get back less than you started with.

The Financial Conduct Authority does not regulate Tax Advice, Trusts or wills. Alan Steel Asset Management Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. The guidance contained in this website is subject to the regulatory regime of the UK.

The Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS) is an agency for arbitrating on unresolved complaints between regulated firms and their clients.

FOS details can be found at www.financial-ombudsman.org.uk

Alan Steel Asset Management Limited are not responsible for the content of external sites.

  • Cookie Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Website terms and conditions
  • Tax Services Privacy Notice
  • Contact Us

This site uses cookies. By using this site you agree to the use of cookies. Read our Cookie Policy